VP, Customer Care
Who we are:
Through a partnership-based approach, Coterie helps insurance professionals unlock untapped revenue in the small commercial space. With an innovative quoting platform that delivers accurate pricing and bindable quotes in less than one minute, Coterie makes small business insurance effortless.
We are on a mission to build and foster a world-class team to bring speed, simplicity, and service to commercial insurance. We value integrity, humility, passion, and intelligence. If you want to push yourself and reshape a $200B+ market, we’re excited to talk to you!
Position Summary:
The VP, Customer Care is the leader responsible for building and running the Service Center and the scalable Care Center around it: the organizational structure, leadership team, operating model, sourcing strategy, and technology foundation required to support the company’s growth. Reporting to executive leadership, this role ensures agents and policyholders receive consistent, high-quality experience while the operation grows efficiently and predictably.
This leader owns the Care Center budget and end-to-end service delivery across calls, chats, emails, and digital channels, supporting policy changes, endorsements, payments, renewals, claims inquiries, and escalations. A core part of the role is determining the right blend of in-house teams, outsourced partners, automation, and AI to deliver that service, in close partnership with Sales, Underwriting, Claims, Product, Technology, Procurement, and Compliance.
At Coterie, service is part of how we grow. Thousands of independent agents, brokers, and digital partners rely on us to make small business insurance easy, and every call, chat, and email either strengthens that relationship or puts it at risk. When an agent gets a fast, knowledgeable answer, they send us their next submission. When a policyholder who bought coverage through a partner has a smooth experience, they renew. The Care Center serves two audiences, agents and policyholders, each with different needs. Its performance shows up directly in retention, partner loyalty, and revenue.
Key Responsibilities:
- Design and implement a scalable Care Center operating model, including organizational structure, support tiers, specialized queues (agent vs. policyholder, billing, claims inquiries, escalations), spans of control, and service level standards.
- Define roles, career paths, and the leadership hierarchy needed to grow volume and headcount without degrading service.
- Establish workforce management practices, including forecasting, capacity planning, scheduling, and staffing ratios, that flex with growth, seasonality, and new product launches.
- Build, lead, and develop a high-performing leadership team of directors and managers, including identifying talent, setting accountability through scorecards and goals, making difficult personnel decisions, and building succession plans for key roles.
- Build and launch the Service Center inside the Coterie Care Center, owning site and channel setup, systems readiness, and go-live, and hiring and training the founding team.
- Run day-to-day Service Center operations against clear performance standards (service level, handle time, quality, first-contact resolution, satisfaction), including real-time queue management, quality and coaching programs, and readiness for volume spikes from renewals, billing cycles, catastrophe events, and new product launches.
- Develop and maintain standardized processes, SOPs, escalation protocols, and knowledge management practices that keep the operation consistent across teams, locations, and partners.
- Establish KPIs, reporting frameworks, and executive dashboards, with a regular cadence of weekly operating metrics, monthly business reviews, and quarterly strategy reviews.
- Own the Care Center budget and serve as its primary point of accountability to executive leadership, reporting on performance, cost-to-serve, customer experience, emerging risks, and investment priorities.
- Develop and execute outsourcing strategy, including deciding which work stays in-house and which is outsourced (overflow, after-hours, seasonal peaks, back-office processing) based on complexity, regulatory risk, cost, and customer impact.
- Lead BPO partner selection, contracting, onboarding, and transition with Procurement, Legal, and Compliance, and hold partners to internal standards through SLAs, scorecards, business reviews, and audit rights.
- Identify and lead opportunities to apply self-service, automation, and AI to high-volume contact drivers, and measure the impact on containment, handle time, quality, cost-to-serve, and customer and agent satisfaction.
- Partner with Technology, Product, Security, and Compliance to evaluate and implement CRM, telephony/CCaaS, workforce management, and AI solutions with appropriate human oversight, testing, and controls.
- Develop business cases and multi-year roadmaps for staffing, outsourcing, technology, and AI investments, with clear ROI and success measures.
- Drive continuous improvement and root-cause analysis to improve first-contact resolution and reduce avoidable contact volume.
- Collaborate with Sales, Underwriting, Claims, Product, and Technology to ensure operational readiness for new products, initiatives, and system changes.
- Ensure Care Center operations and outsourced partners meet licensing, regulatory, security, privacy, and audit requirements, partnering with Legal, Compliance, and Internal audit.
Required Qualifications:
- Bachelor’s Degree in Business, Operations Management, or related field required; MBA preferred.
- 10+ years leading large, multi-channel contact center organizations, including senior leadership roles with budget ownership and a proven track record of scaling an operation through significant growth.
- Insurance industry experience, ideally in property and casualty.
- Demonstrated experience designing organizational structures and hiring, developing, and when necessary, exiting leaders at multiple levels.
- Hands-on experience evaluating, contracting, and managing outsourced/BPO partners, including vendor governance and SLA management.
- Experience selecting and implementing contact center automation and AI solutions (e.g., conversational AI, agent assist, speech analytics) with measurable implementations
Knowledge, Skills and Abilities:
- Strong strategic and operational leadership capabilities.
- Working knowledge of policy servicing, billing, renewals, claims, and the regulatory standards that govern them.
- Deep expertise in workforce management, forecasting, capacity planning, and service level management.
- Proficiency in continuous improvement methods such as Lean or Six Sigma.
- Strong analytical skills with the ability to translate data into actionable insights.
- Ability to manage multiple priorities and initiatives simultaneously in a fast-paced environment.
- Excellent communication, collaboration, and stakeholder management skills.
- Proven ability to build scalable processes and drive operational improvement.
- Executive presence, with experience presenting business cases, performance, risk, and investment recommendations to executive leadership.
- Problem solving mindset.
Our interview process:
Our hiring process generally consists of 4 phases. The goal is to provide an opportunity for us to learn more about our candidates while allowing them to get to know us as well!
- Phase 1: Qualified candidates will first meet with a member of our People Operations team for a phone interview. This discussion is a high-level conversation to understand more about your background and interests and for us to share more about Coterie and the position.
- Phase 2: Selected candidates will be invited to meet with our Hiring Manager for a 2nd interview via Teams video. This interview is designed to be more detail oriented and allows you to learn more about the role and expected to be 30 minutes in length.
- Phase 3: Top candidates will be invited to participate in an experiential interview exercise, which includes a project provided in advance. During the interview, candidates will have a 1-hour session with the hiring manager to present and discuss their project, followed by additional 1:1 interviews with team members. The full interview series is expected to take approximately 2-3 hours.
- Phase 4: Final candidates will receive an invite to our final interview that will include a 1:1 interview with a member of our senior leadership team. The final interview is roughly 30 minutes.
What's in it for you:
Coterie has excellent benefits for all full-time employees. We offer the following:
- 100% remote
- Health insurance through Aetna (we pay 100% of premiums)
- Dental and vision insurance through Guardian (we pay 100% of premiums)
- Basic life insurance (we pay 100% of premiums)
- Access to flexible spending account (FSA) or health savings account (HSA) (for those using HSA eligible plans)
- 401K plan (up 4% match with immediate vest). Must be 21 years of age or older to participate
- Flexible PTO is expected to align with business needs and generally does not exceed approximately 5 weeks per calendar year.
- 12 company-paid holidays each year
- Continuing education annual stipend
- Annual base salary is estimated between $170,000-$200,000 based on national data. This position is also eligible for an annual Short-Term Incentive (STI) bonus based on company performance. Candidates who meet all the minimum requirements and possess additional relevant experience, as outlined in the job description, may be considered for a salary above the midpoint of the above range. Salary is based on internal equity; internal salary ranges; market data/ranges; applicant’s skills; prior relevant experience; degrees or certifications, etc.
Work Authorization:
At this time, Coterie Insurance is unable to consider candidates who require current or future visa sponsorship. Applicants must have authorization to work in the United States without the need for sponsorship now or in the future. Falsification of an application, including work authorization status, is immediate grounds for dismissal from consideration.
Revenue
Remote (United States)
Partager sur :